When end of life conversations go wrong: 4 recommendations for recovery

Tuesday, 23 Apr 2013 11:45

About Dr. Monica Williams-Murphy (120 Posts)

Dr. Monica Williams-Murphy is a Board Certified Emergency Medicine Physician, who practices in one of the largest emergency departments in the United States at Huntsville Hospital. Through her writing and speaking, she is devoted to transforming the end of life into a time of peace, closure and healing. Media Page

I write a lot about end of life conversations that go well or have unexpectedly positive outcomes. But to be fair and balanced, you should also hear about the ones that don’t go so well, lest you be led to believe that I have magical powers over my patients and their families.

Here are two of my attempted “end of life map” conversations that did not go over so well. In fact, these conversations left me speechless…I once took care of a beautiful elderly lady with snow white hair and due to her severe anemia, her skin had nearly the same hue. Looking back over her old records, I recognized a tell-tale pattern for the end of life: She had increasing numbers of recent hospitalizations and was functionally declining fairly rapidly, becoming weaker and weaker. The previous month she could walk with a walker but for the last few weeks she had become bedbound. I steadied myself for an end-of-life mapping conversation to follow my explanation of the blood transfusion we were arranging that day. I remember saying words like “I want to give you a very honest picture of what is going on…. this pattern often means that she is nearing the end of life…”

Before I could start my next phrase, an adult son interrupted me, “Doctor, my mother isn’t going to die. You don’t understand, we are praying that the rapture comes first so that, she will not die and we will all remain together. We have faith that this will happen. Plus, we don’t necessarily believe that her health “pattern” means she is dying.” (And that was that!)

My second encounter was also an elderly female, and this diminutive lady with advanced dementia was also surrounded by a loving and doting family. As I discussed “code status” for the purposes of this hospitalization for my patient, her son also spoke up, but he said: “Who wants to die on a machine? Not Mother!”

“Great!” I thought, these people “get it.” So, I busied myself writing the family’s stated wishes, which did include full medical treatment but no CPR, shocks or breathing machines should their mother’s body fail. In our hospital we call this a “Limited resuscitation” order with DNR.

I had originally asked if there was anyone else in the family whom I needed to talk to and the initial answer was “No.” But, shortly thereafter, an out-of-state daughter called identifying herself as the “Power of Attorney” and said, “I want you to take the DNR order off, because this means you won’t do anything to help her.” I politely attempted to explain otherwise, responding, “No, I actually had filled out a “Limited Resuscitation” order which directs doctors to do everything but place her on machines. And above all, “I emphasized, “we will help her to be as comfortable as she can be no matter what kind of treatment she is receiving.”

Her response: “Well, I’m a nurse and I don’t believe you.” (Ouch!)

Alright now, let’s all take a deep breath… and switch gears to think about what happened in each of these cases. Both of these scenarios ultimately involve distrust or disbelief of me, the healthcare provider. Either my assessment of the situation was disbelieved or my stated plan for the patient was disbelieved.

Now, I didn’t have any magic tricks at the time to overcome their disbelief, but in retrospect, I should have worked harder to gain their trust. Since those two encounters, I have thought long and hard about what I could have done differently or what another more enlightened healthcare provider might have done instead. In response,I have come up with 4 recommendations for myself or anyone else in a similar dilemma:

  • Trust first: We healthcare providers should first trust the idea that the family members may in fact have the best notions about how to care for the patient. This is hard to do. Frequently I walk into the room thinking that I already know what is best for the patient. We just might gain trust by dropping these preconceived notions and instead, becoming open and non-judgmental toward those involved. I should try harder to understand where they are coming from before I try to communicate where I am coming from. So, I have learned that I should listen and trust first.
  • Be vulnerable: Tell your own story about how you struggled to make the best decision for someone that you have loved- take off the healthcare provider hat for a moment and just be human. This breeds empathy, they will then empathize with you!
  • Demonstrate your moral ethic: I know that you are ultimately devoted to what is best for the patient. Verbalized this. It’s powerful to say, “I want to do my best to do what is best for your loved one…” Or “It is morally important for me to tell you the truth about your medical situation”
  • Be very honest: Sometimes the bald-faced truth must be stated, but it can be delivered compassionately. “I know this is so hard to hear, and I want to talk to you as though you are my brother….(insert truth here).”

Alright, so remember, the next time your end of life conversations go wrong…you are not alone. Although I do not have any magic tricks for you, I do hope you will consider trying one or all of these recommendations. After all, when end of life conversations are going wrong, what do you have to lose?

Monica Williams-Murphy, MD

(As always, elements of these patient stories have been altered to protect the privacy of the patient and the family. Date of publication has no relevance to the date of the actual patient encounter.)

Our Book: It's OK to Die

"It's OK to Die" is a ground-breaking book filled with graphic stories straight out of the Emergency Room illustrating how most Americans are completely unprepared for death and dying. In response, the authors have created a unique and comprehensive guide urging EVERYONE to prepare in advance, to assure their own peace and to prevent the suffering of their loved ones.
Learn More..

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.